Blog

Why Can't Hermosa Beach Decide Whether December Parking Should Be Free?

"I can already see my AI posters all over town as the Grinch," Mayor Mike Detoy said just before he cast the deciding vote, according to Easy Reader News.

On October 13, the Hermosa Beach City Council voted 3–2 to suspend the city's complimentary holiday parking program for 2026. Detoy and Councilmembers Michael Keegan and Rob Saemann voted yes. Councilmembers Ray Jackson and Dean Francois voted no. The program covers the city's 388 silver-post meters in the commercial zones, and last year it ran three weeks, from December 3 through Christmas. Two weeks after the vote, Saemann asked to bring the program back, and the item was on the council's November 10 agenda.

The argument behind the reversal matters more than any single vote. Hermosa has offered free holiday parking in some form since 2013, and it still has no number showing whether bagged meters bring in more December business than they cost. This year's suspension was partly an attempt to get that number.

What the meters cost, by the city's own math

City staff can calculate the cost side precisely. The staff report for the November 10 meeting, prepared by Senior Management Analyst Ken Bales, priced a three-week program running December 3 through 25, 2026.

Item Staff estimate
Lost meter revenue, three weeks $158,900
Lost citation revenue, three weeks $41,500
Total, three weeks about $200,400
Cost per week $66,795
Four-week program, as estimated in October close to $270,000

Those figures were disputed at the October meeting, Easy Reader reported. Francois argued that staff had used gross enforcement revenue instead of net revenue after credit card fees, vendor fees and enforcement costs. A resident replied that Francois was leaning on 2024 figures from before parking rates were adjusted. Even so, the cost side gets argued in dollars. The benefit side has no dollar figure.

The number nobody has

"There is limited evidence demonstrating that the resulting economic activity offsets the city's subsidy," Bales told the council, per Easy Reader's October 15 report. A year earlier, the council had asked the Chamber of Commerce for foot-traffic data from the analytics firm Placer.ai.

When business owners returned on October 27, Chamber President Michelle Crispin explained why that evidence is so hard to produce. "Sales taxes are reported quarterly so we can't isolate December sales or put an exact dollar amount on the impact of free parking," she said, as Easy Reader reported on October 28. December gets blended into a quarter with October and November, so the effect of three free weeks can't be separated from everything else in the sales tax data.

Merchants offered the evidence they do have. Lori Ford, who co-owns Gum Tree on Pier Avenue, said the store does 25% of its sales in December and has asked for the program every year for 18 years. Gina Rothwell, who has owned Sol Baby on Pier Avenue for 20 years, pointed out that Hermosa is the smallest of the three beach cities and has the least retail. A representative of Sand Spa said that going from three weeks last year to zero this year removes one of the few tools small shops have during their most important stretch. Uncorked co-owner Kathy Knoll said she would ask for at least three weeks.

Detoy's case for suspending the program came straight out of the data gap. "I think the cleanest way to get data is not to do it one year and to do four weeks the next year," he said. The November staff report states the October direction the same way: suspend the program for 2026 and collect parking data for the month of December. A free December can't produce its own comparison, so the city would need a paid one to measure against.

Why the budget keeps the question open

This argument isn't new, and money has settled it before. Keegan reminded the council that the city cut the program to two weeks in 2009, during the last financial crisis. Since then the length has moved around: three weeks in 2017 and 2025, and four weeks every year from 2018 through 2024, when the council was trying to match Manhattan Beach and Redondo Beach.

The pressure behind this year's vote hasn't eased. Detoy noted the council had already cut more than $4 million from this year's budget. Keegan described a structural deficit and told the room, "There's going to be a lot of disappointment in the community over the next two years based on our budgeting." Jackson, who voted to keep a program, still said, "Believe me, I'd love to give parking away for four weeks, but we can't afford it."

Measure HB, the proposed half-cent sales tax on the November 3 ballot, would have been one source of new revenue. In the Los Angeles County results timestamped November 8, 2026, it was failing with 3,726 yes votes, or 42.77%, against 4,985 no votes, or 57.23%. With that count, the $66,795-a-week cost of free parking stays in a budget the council itself calls tight, and the holiday parking question will likely come back next fall.

The options on the November 10 agenda

The reconsideration came to the council with a wide range of options on the record:

  1. No program, the October 13 decision, with December used to collect parking data.
  2. Two weeks, December 11 through 25, Saemann's proposal when he asked for reconsideration.
  3. Three weeks, December 3 through 25, the scenario staff priced at about $200,400.
  4. Weekends only, Fridays through Sundays from Thanksgiving to Christmas, suggested by Jani Lang, who runs a sales agency serving specialty retailers.

Staff didn't recommend any one of these. The report asked the council to "discuss and provide direction." The city posts summaries of each council meeting on its City Council meeting recap page, and that page carries the October 27 request that put this item back on the agenda.

The neighbors set the comparison. According to the Hermosa staff report, Manhattan Beach had authorized four weeks running from Thanksgiving through Christmas Day, and Redondo Beach was discussing one week during Christmas week. Redondo Councilmember Brad Waller wrote in his June newsletter that he had kept the Riviera Village free-parking week in that city's budget.

The December calendar runs on fixed dates either way

Downtown Hermosa's holiday events are scheduled regardless of what happens with the meters, and the biggest one falls before any of the proposed free windows. Even the earliest option, Lang's weekends from Thanksgiving, would start November 27.

Hermosa for the Holidays, November 21 and 22. The Hermosa Beach Chamber Foundation presents the weekend with the city.

  • Saturday: a Pier Plaza pop-up market and Santa letters from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., a concert from 2 to 7 p.m., and a Ferris wheel from noon to 9 p.m.
  • Sunday: Santa photos and brand activations from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., a nonprofit village from 1 to 6 p.m., Rock for Tots programming, and the tree lighting with Santa's arrival on Pier Plaza from 5:45 to 6:15 p.m.

Sand Snowman Contest, December 5. It runs from 9 a.m. to noon at 15th Street and the shoreline. Registration opens at 9 a.m. and judging starts at 11:15 a.m. The date falls inside the three-week window staff priced and outside Saemann's two-week window.

Community Chanukah Celebration, December 6. The Jewish Community Center hosts entertainment, activities and a menorah lighting on Pier Plaza from 3 to 5 p.m.

California Great Santa Stroll, December 12. Mychal's Learning Place hosts this fundraiser walk from 9 a.m. to noon. It starts at Pier Plaza, 1 Pier Avenue, and ends at the Manhattan Beach Pier.

Street work is also part of the downtown picture. The city's October 6 notice said Phase 3 sewer rehabilitation on Hermosa Avenue began October 5 and was expected to continue through mid-November. The work brought temporary parking and travel-lane closures on Hermosa Avenue, traffic control and alley closures on Palm Drive, and possible sidewalk restrictions. As part of that sewer project's restoration, the Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts will repave and reinstall the decorative pavement at Hermosa and Pier avenues using the city's updated logo, at the Districts' cost.

The businesses that depend on December traffic are also changing. Kasai Records, a Tokyo-inspired restaurant and listening bar from Ryan Stock and Skylar Tourigny, opened at 1332 Hermosa Avenue with dinner Wednesday through Sunday and weekend brunch. In October, Patrick Mescall and Brian Eldridge took over Java Man at 157 Pier Avenue and Ocean Diner and said they plan to keep both places' character and staff, Easy Reader reported. Whatever the council settles on for this December, these are the storefronts whose December sales will either be measured against a paid month or remain blended into a quarterly sales tax report.

If you own near Pier Avenue or downtown and want to know how the city's budget choices could show up in what buyers ask about your block, May-Ann Fisher follows these council decisions as part of pricing Hermosa homes. Book a Consultation and we'll go through what's changing downtown and what it means for your sale or purchase timeline.

Experience the Difference

Discover the unique value of working with May-Ann that truly cares about your success.
Let's Connect
Follow Us